My husband and I are atheists, but we have never focused on that with our kids. We decided to wait until they are older (they are 5 and 7 now) before we explain exactly what our beliefs are. We are trying to avoid indoctrinating them into atheism, as it were. We’d prefer they grow up with an open mind and decide for themselves.
Instead of religion, we’ve focused on skepticism, logic, and reason. They ask us questions and frequently we respond with “What do you think?”. We try to encourage them to think for themselves, and question explanations that others give them. Look for facts. Be logical. Have proof before you accept.
At the same time we have exposed them to some of the religion they’ll encounter in their bible-belt hometown. When they were each four, we enrolled them in the best preschool in town, which happens to be at a Lutheran church, where they learned bible stories and went to chapel. We celebrate Christmas and Easter every year, while explaining the history of how these holidays came about. But we have never said, regarding the stories they learned in chapel and at Christmastime, “Well, sweetheart, they just aren’t true.”
This leads to doubt on my part. Am I doing enough? They learned about Jesus and God in preschool. I read them books about the Christmas story. They’ve been exposed to Christianity through other family members, and through the media. I never refuted any of it. Am I unwittingly raising Christians?
Then last weekend during a drive, we heard church bells and my daughter, 7-year-old Little Skeptic Girl, proved she’s not too young to be a freethinker:
LSG: “That’s pretty music!”
Me: “Yes, it’s from the bells in that church.”
LSG: “Mommy, do we not go to church because there are no churches around here that teach what we believe, or do we not go to church because there are no churches that teach what we believe?”
Me: “I guess the answer to that is that no church teaches what Daddy and I believe. There are many, many different kinds of churches in the world, and they all teach different things. My question is, which is right? And who am I to say which is right? The one thing most of them have in common is they teach that there is a supernatural being who has power over this world and the people in it. I decided a long time ago that I don’t believe there is a supernatural being who has power over the world. I believe the world is explained by science, and I don’t need to explain what I don’t understand by claiming it is because of a supernatural being. But Daddy and I want you to learn as much as you can and decide for yourself when you get older what it is you believe.”
LSG: “Yeah, because I remember learning in preschool that God used to talk to Moses and Noah all the time, but now you can only talk to God through prayer, and He never answers you out loud. And I thought, that doesn’t make any sense!”
That’s my little skeptic!